Sunday, January 29, 2012

NFL Pro Bowl or NHL All Star Game?


Since the NFL changed the date of the Pro Bowl from the week after the Super Bowl to the week before two years ago, it has coincided with the NHL’s All Star Game on the same day. Now, in the US, Football is much more popular than hockey; it shouldn’t even be an argument. But when it comes to All Star games? Festivities? That’s a whole different story… hockey’s got that in the bag. Especially since they implemented the fantasy draft system last season, maybe in efforts to have an extra edge on the NFL since they became competition, it’s been a much more entertaining weekend, about on par with the NBA and MLB.

Like I said earlier, Football might be the country’s favorite sport, but when your all star game takes place in Hawaii every year, when players from the most elite of teams are no longer able to play because they have to prepare for the Super Bowl next week, when there’s nothing else besides the game, which is usually lackluster, is it even worth watching?

The NHL’s All Star game is three hours before the NFL’s, presumably because they don’t want to deal with the competition. But honestly, as someone who is more of a football fan than hockey, I would much rather watch the NHL All Star Game. People have the whole weekend to get into it, from Friday’s Draft, to Saturday’s Skills Challenge, the league does a great job hyping up its most star-studded game of the year. I didn’t watch the All Star festivities last season just because I wasn’t home, but after watching the draft this year and watching the festivities last night, I’m more excited for today’s All Star Game than I’ve ever been for a Pro Bowl… even when the Eagles had four starters after the 2004 season.

Then again, that could’ve been because they had just lost the Super Bowl…

Regardless, I understand these All Star games are for fun. They’re not supposed to be competitive. Even in MLB, where the winner gets home-field advantage in the World Series, you don’t usually see serious competitiveness until halfway into the game. But the NHL has been on its way back up in popularity since the lockout in 2005. It’s not close to the NFL, but the Pro Bowl is nowhere near any of the other major sports’ All Star games. The NHL was better before, and with the league’s added all star events, it only widened the gap.

As I write this, the All Star Game is about to begin. So I’ll end with saying that, although Hockey isn’t as popular, it surely tries much harder to make for a successful and fun All Star Weekend. Football just goes on the name and hope people will watch because people always watch. It’s a Sunday. It’s a habit. But I, for one, will not be sucked in. I watch football 21 out of 22 Sundays from September to February. On this Sunday, Hockey gets the nod.

No comments:

Post a Comment